Name: Goodfellas Pizzeria
Address: 745 W Market St, Niagara Falls, NY, Niagara Falls, NY, US
Telephone: 716-285-8448
Rating: 2.8

🏷️ Dishes/Highlights

Pizza - Wings - Steak & Cheese Sub - Stromboli - chicken Souvlaki - Delivery

📋 Menu

Pizza

Personal Pie Cheese Pizza $10.96

Medium Pie Cheese Pizza $15.90

Large Pie Cheese Pizza $18.96

Half Tray Pizza Cheese $15.96

Tray Pizza Cheese $29.98

Slice Cheese $2.00

Slice Pep $2.50

Specialty Pizza

White Pizza $18.98

Chicken Finger Pizza $18.98

Steak Pizza $18.98

Gluten Free Pie $12.96

Cauliflower Crust $11.96

Old Fashioned Pizza

Large Old Fashioned $18.98

Medium Old Fashioned $15.98

Half Tray Old Fashioned $14.98

Full Tray Old Fashioned $26.98

Wings & Specials

10 Wings $14.98

20 Wings $26.98

30 Wings $40.98

50 Wings $65.98

1/2 Tray Pizza w/ Cheese & 20 Wings $40.98

Full Tray Pizza w/ Cheese & 30 Wings $65.98

Full Tray Pizza w/ Cheese & 50 Wings $77.96

Finger Foods

Pizza Logs $9.98

5 pieces

Jalapeno Poppers $7.98

8 pieces

Mozzarella Sticks $8.98

5 pieces

Fried Ravioli $8.96

12 pieces

Garlic Bread w/ Cheese $6.98

Chicken Fingers

4 Fingers $11.98

8 Fingers $23.98

12 Fingers $33.98

3 Fingers w/ Fries $11.98

Sides & Extras

Small Fry $4.98

Large Fry $5.98

Small Poutine $7.98

Large Poutine $9.98

Onion Rings $5.98

Sm Fry Mozz Cheese $5.96

Lg Fry Mozz Cheese $6.00

Extra Blue Cheese $1.25

Extra Side Sauce $1.50

Blue Cheese $1.50

Side Gravy $1.75

Sour Cream $1.00

Salsa $1.25

Side Honey Garlic $1.50

Ranch $1.50

Side BBQ $1.50

Side Hot Sauce $1.50

Side Medium Sauce $0.98

Side of Ketchup $0.75

2 or cup

Salads

Dinner Salad $5.25

Chef Salad $9.98

Grilled Chicken Salad $13.98

Chicken Finger Salad $13.98

Antipasto $13.99

Chicken Taco Bowl Salad $13.50

Regular Subs

Steak & Cheese $11.90

Sausage & Cheese $11.90

Ham & Cheese $11.90

Assorted & Cheese $11.90

Turkey & Oil $11.90

Tuna & Cheese $11.30

Salami & Cheese $11.30

Capicola & Cheese $11.30

BLT Sub $11.00

Ovflurger Sub $11.36

Specialty Subs

Singer Sub $14.98

Royal $14.98

Chicken Parmesan $12.00

Meatball Sub $12.00

Chicken Finger Sub $11.00

Giant Tacos

Steak Taco $10.00

2 pieces

Chicken Taco $12.98

Stinger Taco $12.98

Sandwiches & Burgers

1/2 lb Hamburger w/ Fries $12.96

Grilled Chicken Sandwich $12.98

Dinners

Pasta Dinner w/ Meatballs $13.98

Fish Fry $14.90

Dottie's Chicken Soup

Pint of Soup $7.00

Sept-June Only

Quart of Soup $13.70

Sept-June Only

Desserts

Fried Dough $3.75

12 pieces

2 Liter Bottles

Coca-Cola $2.99

Diet Coke $2.99

Coca-Cola Cherry $2.99

Coca-Cola Zero Sugar $2.99

Cherry Coke $2.99

Sprite $2.30

Fanta Orange $2.30

Gingersale $2.39

Rootbeer $2.39

Loganberry $2.39

Minute Maid Fruit Punch $2.09

Gold Peak Sweet Tea $2.00

Gold Peak Tea & Lemonade $2.00

Minute Maid Lemonade $2.00

20 Oz Bottles

Coca-Cola $2.30

Diet Coke $2.30

Sprite $2.30

Ginger Ale $2.00

Dasani Water $2.00

🌟 Specials

No specials posted yet — be the first to add one!

🕐 Hours

Mon 11am-12am

Tue 11am-12am

Wed 11am-12am

Thu 11am-12am

Fri 11am-12am

Sat 11am-12am

Sun 11am-12am

Hours may vary for holidays. Confirm directly with the restaurant.

Is this menu out of date or information incorrect? Help the community!

ℹ️ Info

Address745 W Market St, Niagara Falls, NY

Phone716-285-8448

CuisinePizza - Italian

City Niagara Falls →

Deals Deals & Specials →

📊 All-Time Stats

Most Liked in Niagara Falls

1,283

total likes

🏆 Top in Niagara Falls

All Niagara Falls Restaurants →