Name: Tiki Bar Amara Cay
Address: 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL, Islamorada, FL, US
Telephone: 305-664-0073

🏷️ Dishes/Highlights

Baja-Style Tacos - Smash Burgers - Blackened Fish Sandwich - Flatbreads - Cocktails - Onsite Amara Cay Resort - Happy Hour

📋 Menu

Handhelds

Baja-Style Tacos $19.00

Three warmed flour tortillas, cilantro, cabbage slaw, tropical salsa, fresh guacamole, pickled red onion. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap $19.00

Grilled or crispy chicken, romaine, parmesan, roasted tomato, poblano and avocado ranch, bacon, grilled tortilla. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Local Catch Shrimp $23.00

Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Local Catch Steak $26.00

Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Fresh Catch Po'Boy $24.00

Crispy battered local catch, toasted hoagie roll, spicy remoulade cabbage slaw, tomato, red onion. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Bacon Jam Burger $22.00

Juicy flame-grilled beef double patty topped with a rich house-made bacon jam, melted cheddar cheese, on a brioche bun. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Tropical Bites Smash Burger $22.00

American cheese, caramelized onions, pineapple relish, chipotle slaw, brioche bun. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Lobster Grilled Cheese $30.00

Cold water lobster, three-cheese blend, grain mustard aioli, thick-sliced sourdough. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Blackened Fish Sandwich $23.00

Local catch, cabbage slaw, tomato, grilled red onion, key lime tartar, avocado, toasted brioche bun. Served with house made seasoned chips, substitute for fries. Add on: chicken steak 14, shrimp 10, lobster 18, sauteed veggies 5

Flatbreads

Three-Cheese $18.00

red sauce, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan

SBLT $25.00

marinated shrimp, old bay, applewood-smoked bacon, arugula, roasted tomato

Philly $22.00

thinly sliced steak, caramelized onions, roasted bell peppers, blend of melted cheeses

Desserts

Chocolate Brownie Sundae $12.00

warm chocolate brownie, vanilla ice cream, chocolate drizzle

Key Lime Pie $14.00

creamy, tart key lime filling nestled in a toasted graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream

Coconut Bread Pudding $13.00

brioche bread pudding infused with coconut, served warm with irish cream sauce

Vanilla Ice Cream $10.00

Classic Beignets $10.00

light, airy beignets dusted with powdered sugar, served with pineapple rum caramel sauce

🌟 Specials

No specials posted yet — be the first to add one!

🕐 Hours

Mon 11:30am-11pm

Tue 11:30am-11pm

Wed 11:30am-11pm

Thu 11:30am-11pm

Fri 11:30am-11pm

Sat 11:30am-11pm

Sun 11:30am-11pm

Hours may vary for holidays. Confirm directly with the restaurant.

Is this menu out of date or information incorrect? Help the community!

ℹ️ Info

Address80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL

Phone305-664-0073

CuisineHotel Bar

City Islamorada →

Deals Deals & Specials →

📊 All-Time Stats

#60

Most Liked in Islamorada

total likes

🏆 Top in Islamorada

All Islamorada Restaurants →